An Arbitrary Grading of Our Themes for 2026


Always a crowd favorite, our “12 Themes,” for the following year, debuted nearly four years ago. As in years past, we thought it would be fun to revisit the predictions and see how they turned out. With the benefit of hindsight, we’ve graded each theme (completely arbitrarily) based on its relevance and accuracy to what actually transpired.
Our 2026 themes earned an overall B-. In many ways, 2026 was an extension of the lessons from 2025, this time compounded by the Middle East conflict and shifting sentiment around the hyperscalers. Heavier retail participation, trading driven by sentiment more than fundamentals, and a run of geopolitical shocks all fed higher volatility and ambiguity in the market.
1. AI Industrial Revolution
(Grade: A-)
The core thesis was right: the companies making the hardware behind AI, the chipmakers above all, had a huge run into June. The issue was the market bought in quickly, creating a steep overbought condition, which has resulted in a correction into the second half of the year as investors have started asking for proof of generating real returns on these investments. The cloud piece is still questionable; while it has grown meaningfully, there are still many outstanding questions surrounding cloud’s proposed utility.
2. Alternative Strategies Thrive
(Grade: C-)
This one didn’t work. Crypto fell and gold & silver went mostly sideways after their enormous 2025, as the expectation of higher-for-longer rates caused a rotation into fixed income. Commodities, and managed futures were the right calls in the end in terms of outperformance, though our underlying reasoning for that performance didn’t quite hold. The surge in commodity and energy prices was primarily on the back of the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and while managed futures did outperform, divergent rate decisions were not the primary driver.
3. Power Up
(Grade: A)
Right as an idea. AI is clearly pushing up electricity demand and the grid is the bottleneck. That being said, performance in the sector throughout the year is slightly mixed.
4. Stablecoins
(Grade: A-)
Adoption grew quickly and the market was helped by the GENIUS Act (takes effect early 2027) bringing banks and large institutions in. Though the overall growth in the market was modest.
5. Job Markets Stay Soft
(Grade: B-)
Half right. Hiring and job openings stayed soft, however while the expected US unemployment rate was 4.4-4.5%, it went down slightly to about 4.2%, largely due to a low-hire/low-fire equilibrium and a decreasing labor force.
6. Inflation Continues to Cool
(Grade: F)
Inflation stayed sticky, and rather than cutting further, the Fed held for the majority of the year and raised rates in September, its first hike since 2023. The oil shock back in March didn't help either as an unexpected global event took place in the Middle East.
7. AI Investment Supercycle
(Grade: B+)
AI stayed the biggest story of the year and remained the dominant investment theme. The worry that the spending might not earn its keep turned out to be fair, and it showed up in the mid-year pullback. The one material miss was China tech, which didn’t come through, though this is in line with one of our key risks listed; concerns about returns on invested capital and the speed of capital deployment.
8. Monetary Policy Divergence
(Grade: C)
The call on elevated global rates and high debt burdens was accurate. While monetary policy diverged across major central banks earlier in the year, geopolitical factors later pulled them in a similar direction, to varying degrees. The expectation of the Fed to deliver 2-3 cuts over the year was off the mark. Sticky inflation led to holding and a hike later in the year, and while small-caps have had a surge in 2026, they have cooled down recently due to rates.
9. Sector Rotation/Value vs Growth
(Grade: B)
A mixed bag. Materials outperformed slightly while Industrials underperformed, each to a varying degree and not without interim volatility. Healthcare has been improving, though sector rotations came later in the year. The big miss was underweight energy, with it turning out to be the best sector of the year, though this was on the back of the geopolitical environment and has come with an increase in volatility. Utilities and staples also performed similarly well to industrials while consumer discretionary was amongst the worst.
10. Caution Around Hyperscalers
(Grade: A+)
The buildout was funded in large part by debt, credit spreads have widened, Oracle was downgraded to the lowest investment grade and the cost to insure its debt jumped, albeit there were no actual defaults. This theme played out as expected. (“Hyperscalers” are companies investing billions in data centre construction to service their cloud computing business.)
11. Opportunities in US Banks
(Grade: C-)
Close on the outcome, wrong on the reason. Banks did remain resilient after a rough start to the year, but we got there expecting a more dovish new Fed chair and rate cuts to help. Instead, the new chair was hawkish and rates were held and went up. Banks did do well on elevated markets activity and performance.
12. US Travel Won't Return in 2026
(Grade: A)
Canadian trips to the US didn’t meaningfully bounce back over the year, and while a large part of this was due to continued negative sentiment, part of it was also driven by elevated fuel costs.
Overall Grade: B-
The key takeaway is one we keep returning to: in periods of heightened uncertainty, investment discipline and diversification matter more than ever. Reactionary trades tend to do the most damage, so staying with established and diversified strategies is central to navigating markets over the long term. A disciplined approach and broad exposure, spanning growth, value/quality equities, and fixed income alike, are meant to help a portfolio generate positive alpha and stand up through the full arc of the macro cycle, not just one.


Comments